Internal childcare licensing agency emails show they don’t want providers to know how to appeal

Licensing employees (LPAs, Program Managers, Regional Managers, etc.) are state government employees, which means their emails are public records, which anyone can ask to see (though certain private or confidential info in the emails will be redacted or withheld). Several months ago I requested emails and other documents from licensing, and I recently received the first batch of documents, which included emails from the licensing Program Administrator and Assistant Program Administrators (the folks who supervise all the Regional Offices). 

Something in the emails was disappointing but not at all surprising. When licensing found out I was trying to help childcare providers to appeal licensing citations, it seems they sought legal advice on how to stop me:

Email from CCLD employee, "A local R&R passed this along. This is a website by Howard Wu, licensee of Aspen Leaf facilities.  He's also got the site Childcare Licensing Appeals where he advertises appeal resources and has a blog.  Just sharing for awareness."
Email from Maria Hendrix, CCLD: "Hello, Sharing with everyone this service brought to our attention by an LPA out of Cindy Interiano's office. Not sure if we want to share this with our legal partners or not.  I can supply the entire email stream if needed, just let me know.  I apprecaite Cindy & Kimberly elevating this information."
Email from Karen Chang, CCLD: "Hi Shanice and Maria, I do think we need to flag for legal.  Kim and Cindy thank you for raising to our awareness."

Of course, there’s nothing their Legal Division can do, because it’s perfectly legal to help providers understand how to appeal. But it is scary and discouraging that the agency is so allergic to accountability. We all have the right to challenge their decisions, but they clearly do not want us to.

These emails show that licensing, from top to bottom, simply wants to be obeyed without question. That is wrong.

Appeal licensing citations like a lawyer.

Get the Licensing Appeal Kit.
Researched & written by a lawyer and preschool owner, for childcare providers.

As a lawyer in private practice, clients used to pay $575 per hour for my time and effort. The guides, templates, research, and real-world appeals in my Licensing Appeal Kit represents over 300 hours of research and work on my part, which I’m making available to every childcare provider in California for the cost of a few children’s books. And for a limited number of providers, I’m offering the Licensing Appeal Kit and a 1-hour consultation with me to talk over any licensing issues whenever they need.

Step-by-Step Guide to Appeal Licensing Citations (eBook only)

$ 49

What you get:

  • My 22-page step-by-step guide to appeal licensing citations (in English & Spanish)
  • Mi guía paso a paso de 22 páginas para apelar citaciones de licencia
or

The Licensing Appeal Kit

$ 99

What you get:

  • My 22-page step-by-step guide to appeal licensing citations (eBook)
  • Mi guía paso a paso de 22 páginas para apelar citaciones de licencia
  • A 9-page guide to help childcare providers understand and handle lawsuits (being sued)
  • Ready-to-use templates for first- and second-level appeals
  • A bulletpoint appeal template that makes it possible to assemble an appeal in less than hour
  • Checklists for children files and teacher files to help you avoid common record-keeping citations
  • Seven real-life examples you’ll have permission to copy from (over 400 pages of material)
  • Templates for licensing waiver requests
  • A pre-written waiver request to commingle toddlers with other age components (updated January 2025, based on PIN 24-01-CCP)
  • Every future update (purchasers are the first to receive new materials)
or

The Licensing Appeal Kit
+ 1-hour consultation

$ 249

What you get:

  • Everything in the Licensing Appeal Kit
  • Every future update (purchasers are the first to receive new materials)
  • A one-hour phone consultation with me to discuss your licensing issue and analyze your appeal (never expires; save it for when you need it)
  • Only 16 currently available
or

Skip to content